Dershowitz, Che, and today’s items

Alan Dershowitz asks Why won’t Carter debate his book?

When Larry King referred to my review several times to challenge Carter, Carter first said I hadn’t read the book and then blustered, “You know, I think it’s a waste of my time and yours to quote professor Dershowitz. He’s so obviously biased, Larry, and it’s not worth my time to waste it on commenting on him.” (He never did answer King’s questions.)

The next week Carter wrote a series of op-eds bemoaning the reception his book had received. He wrote that his “most troubling experience” had been “the rejection of [his] offers to speak” at “university campuses with high Jewish enrollment.” The fact is that Brandeis President Jehuda Reinharz had invited Carter to come to Brandeis to debate me, and Carter refused. The reason Carter gave was this: “There is no need to for me to debate somebody who, in my opinion, knows nothing about the situation in Palestine.”

As Carter knows, I’ve been to Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza, many times — certainly more times than Carter has been there — and I’ve written three books dealing with the subject of Middle Eastern history, politics, and the peace process. The real reason Carter won’t debate me is that I would correct his factual errors. It’s not that I know too little; it’s that I know too much.

Nor is Carter the unbiased observer of the Middle East that he claims to be. He has accepted money and an award from Sheik Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan , saying in 2001: “This award has special significance for me because it is named for my personal friend, Sheik Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan.” This is the same Zayed, the long-time ruler of the United Arab Emirates, whose $2.5 million gift to the Harvard Divinity School was returned in 2004 due to Zayed’s rampant Jew-hatred. Zayed’s personal foundation, the Zayed Center, claims that it was Zionists, rather than Nazis, who “were the people who killed the Jews in Europe” during the Holocaust. It has held lectures on the blood libel and conspiracy theories about Jews and America perpetrating Sept. 11. Carter’s acceptance of money from this biased group casts real doubt on his objectivity and creates an obvious conflict of interest.

Carter’s refusal to debate wouldn’t be so strange if it weren’t for the fact that he claims that he wrote the book precisely so as to start debate over the issue of the Israel-Palestine peace process. If that were really true, Carter would be thrilled to have the opportunity to debate. Authors should be accountable for their ideas and their facts. Books shouldn’t be like chapel, delivered from on high and believed on faith.


Irwin, Echuta, and Val emailed on this: Target Pulls che guevara CD Case from Stores
Here’s why it matters: WSJ (by subscription only)
Guevara is not just a dead white guy from a well-to-do family who terrorized a racially mixed nation and executed hundreds of thousands of innocents in the late 1950s and 1960s. He is also a symbol of the totalitarian regime that persists in Cuba, which still practices his ideology of intolerance, hatred and repression. It is not the torture and killing alone that make the tragedy. That only describes the methodology. Guevara’s wider goal – to forcibly strip a population of its soul and spirit – is what is truly frightening and deplorable. Christians, who celebrate the birth of their Savior on Monday, have particularly suffered under Guevara’s dream of revolution, which has lasted since 1959.


Cinnammon thanks a serviceman at Christmas.

A few articles from Maria
Why radical Islam – and why now?

Bust the joint up

Updates from Germany–War on homeschooling

The world in 2007


Support Border Patrol Agents Ignacio Ramos and Juan Compean of the Fabens, Texas Border Patrol Station

Update: Don’t miss also AP whitewashes Ahmadinejad (again)

4 Responses to “Dershowitz, Che, and today’s items”

  1. Obi's Sister Says:

    Maybe because he didn’t REALLY write it himself?

  2. Fausta Says:

    Maybe because he didn’t REALLY write it himself?
    Won’t be the only former White House resident who’s hiding the ghost (writer)

  3. Obi's Sister Says:

    That’s exactly who I was thinking of….. 😉

  4. Darweesh Qaimari Says:

    The civil war began between the Palestinian people, but everyone ran this talk, the Palestinian people, which has been struggling for more than six decades the Israeli enemy, far worse each other. Should we accuse the Israeli government as some do? Or accuse the Palestinian Authority that they were Hamas or Fatah! Have we forgotten is the occupation? Are we looking at the seats and power? We shouldn’t forget that education in Palestine stopped for a period of two months, the Palestinian ministries stalled for more than four months. Is this what we want and aspire to the Palestinian people under Israeli occupation? After all these questions! So is there a place for celebrations?
    Free Palestine T-shirts, Free Lebanon T-shirts